UKRAINE – IN RETROSPECT, MISSED OPPORTUNITIES, AND INSIGHTS ALONG THE WAY
Back in April 2014, I provided colleagues in the European Parliament with some key findings to be of help when debating the EU package of support to Ukraine and efficient resource allocation. The findings were based on OECD research, discussions and personal input.
In retrospect, here they are as follows and, I presume, some of them are valid as ever:
Key facts
– The growth momentum of the regions of Ukraine enjoyed in the years before the 2008-09 financial crisis was lost. Export demand was subdued. Domestic demand growth was constrained by slow credit growth.
– The degree of centralisation of the fiscal structure was high. The institutional environment was not conducive to investment.
– The Inter-regional disparities continued to increase, including access to basic services, especially education and healthcare.
– The large informal labour market made it difficult to assess labour market trends with precision but the link between education and productivity appeared to be weak.
Key policy issues
– Being a highly centralised polity, there was a wide agreement that Ukraine needed greater decentralisation. Sub-national governments, however, often faced capacity challenges.
– Fragmentation at lower levels made it difficult to realise policies of scale or even to perform basic service provision effectively.
– Sub-national governments tended to depend heavily on central transfers – it was the national budget that prescribed them. The top-down approach made the local finances related to central planning and the lack of autonomy, and respectively, of accountability to the local community was a drawback.
– Regional development policy was undergoing a major legislative and institutional overhaul.
Key recommendations
– Revise the formulae for the allocation of transfers to sub-national tiers of government – to make it simpler and less discretionary, by reducing the number of indicators used in the formula.
– Base the resources allocated for the provision of local public service on the needs of the population in each area, not input indicators.
– Revise the revenue structure of the oblasts to allow them to retain any extra revenue generated at the oblast or local level.
– Implement a territorial reform (valid even more so today) prior to any decentralisation of functions to the lower levels of government in order to allow towns and local communities to reach the necessary scale of capacity building and merging of municipalities.
– Introduce a property tax to enhance municipal financial capacity, preceding its introduction by the creation of a reliable cadastre.
– Create a monitoring system for the effectiveness of the policies implemented, with special reference to local public goods and services.
– Use the State Fund for Regional Development (SFRD), based on EU principles and strategy documents, as an instrument to foster inter regional cooperation.
– Make a rigorous cost-benefit analysis of any special zones or industrial parks, in line with the European and international best practice, to minimise spatial distortions and maximise the zone’s integration with the wider economy. The risks of corruption, distortions and fragmentation are real, and experience suggests that special zones are, at best, a second-best policy option. The first-best option is to generally improve the overall investment climate.
From today’s perspective, it is difficult to say if things are on the path to improvement in the context mentioned above. Lack of access to systematic and comprehensive data on sub-national finance limits the scope of a more comprehensive analysis and also underscores the need for transparency in inter-budgetary relations and predictability at all levels of government.
Mariela Baeva




Leave a Reply